Retiree claims ₹19L leave encash exemption, IT dept caps ₹3L, ITAT gives full relief

Started by Pankaj, Jun 20, 2026, 09:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Pankaj

A man retired from ONGC and got ₹19.05 lakh as leave encashment. It was his own earned leave, built up over years, and he had already paid tax on his salary. He claimed it as tax‑free and filed his return.

The IT Department's CPC limited the exemption to ₹3 lakh and taxed the rest.

Why ₹3 lakh? Because that limit was set back in 2002 and never changed. Meanwhile, government employees enjoyed a much higher exemption for the same retirement benefit.

He appealed. The CIT(A) said no - PSU employees are not government employees, so no parity.

He appealed again before the ITAT in Chennai. This time he won. The tribunal allowed exemption on the full ₹19.05 lakh.

ITAT said the later increase of the leave‑encashment exemption to ₹25 lakh was not a brand‑new benefit; it was just correcting an outdated figure. If it was meant to fix a hardship, denying it to people who retired before the correction creates an unfair distinction.

The government basically accepted that the old ₹3 lakh cap had become unrealistic. But anyone who retired before the correction, and didn't have the time, money, patience or health to fight through CIT(A) and then ITAT, may have simply paid tax on money they could have claimed as exempt.

How many retirees just accepted the notice and paid up?

Hari

It feels like the IT department is the only one working overtime to harass ordinary citizens, while conveniently ignoring those who are clearly avoiding taxes.

Komal

Why is the Income Tax Department not as inefficient as other government departments?

Jyoti.kumar

My dad had a similar problem in 2023 when he retired. His leave encashment was paid six months after retirement, when the ₹25 L rule was in force, and the employer tried to deduct extra tax. I approached the corporate office and quoted the CBDT Gazette notification (Notification No. 31/2023/F. No. 200/3/2023‑ITA‑I); they later agreed after checking. There are many such cases.

Sanjay

Is leave encashment tax‑free only at retirement, or also in other situations?

Nath

Who should we approach in such cases - lawyers or chartered accountants?