Offer withdrawn after asking for written hrs – red flag or norm?

Started by Pillai, Apr 06, 2026, 12:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Pillai

First, I want to sincerely apologise to everyone who took the time to comment on my post this past Saturday. I ended up deleting it in a moment of pure panic and anxiety. You all gave me incredibly solid advice, and I felt bad for nuking the thread after you helped me. I was just really overwhelmed.

For those who didn't see the original post, here's a quick overview of what happened:

My Background & Context To give you an idea of where my head was at, I just officially quit a highly toxic job of 4 years this past Wednesday (April 1st). I spent years in an environment that completely disregarded my boundaries and owned my time. Because of that, my radar for corporate red flags is currently on maximum alert.

The Interview & Red Flags I was interviewing for an SDE IV role (offered at 10.5 LPA). The technical rounds were surprisingly easy. Instead of actually evaluating my skills, they seemed more focused on my daily commute to the office.

Then there was a specific moment that really set off alarm bells. The Operations Manager explicitly told me that "timings depend on the project" and that there are no set working hours. He basically implied that if I was looking for a strict 9‑to‑5, this wasn't the place.

The Offer They sent the offer letter this past Saturday and told me my joining date was Monday, April 6th – basically a 1‑day notice to accept and transition. I reviewed the PDF and noticed:

1. No daily working hours were specified anywhere.
2. No working days (e.g., Monday to Friday) were mentioned.
3. It mandated a strict 1‑month notice period during the 3‑month probation.

What I Did Following the advice I got here, I didn't sign blindly. I replied to the email (copying HR, the Director, and the hiring managers) and politely asked for clarity. I requested that the revised offer letter explicitly state the daily working hours, confirm a standard 5‑day work week, and ask if the 1‑month probation notice could be waived since they were rushing me to join in 24 hrs.

The Result HR called me shortly after. She said she was "not authorized" to put the working hours in the document and claimed these things should have been sorted out during the interview. She told me not to report to the office on Monday while she discussed it with her team.

Then I received an official email from HR stating that my offer of employment is withdrawn, effective immediately.

Their exact reasoning was: *"incorporation of additional or revised terms into the offer letter would require a formal internal and compliance review process. Given the immediate nature of this role and the scheduled joining date... it is not feasible to complete such a process."* So, rather than simply updating the standard working hours in the PDF, they completely pulled the offer.

I was freaking out at first, but looking back, I'm just glad I didn't jump straight from one toxic 4‑year job into another trap. Did I make the right call, or is this kind of HR behaviour just the new normal? How would you have handled this?

Sakshi

Bro, you definitely did the right thing. If they pull the offer just because you asked to clarify work timings, you've dodged a bullet.

Jasmin

Workdays should be specified.

But office hours are never going to be a hard guarantee. Even if they're in the contract, there will be a note that overtime may be needed in some cases, depending on the situation.

Kavitha

You dodged a bullet. Even if they regularly make workers do unpaid overtime, labour laws require the working hours to be mentioned in the employment contract and displayed at the office entrance or near reception.

Kishore

Which company actually specifies both working hours and working days?

Anjali

Please name and shame the company so others can stay away.

Rajendra

Working days can be mentioned, but no company will lock in exact work timings. If it's an MNC and you're later assigned a US project, you can refuse saying the timings breach your contract, so they avoid putting it in the agreement. These things are usually discussed outside the contract – it's India, not Europe.


Sandeep

No company writes working hours in the agreement, dude.

Michael

What does SDE IV mean, buddy? I think you might have overshot a bit, but no worries.

You live and learn. Try clearing all your doubts during the interview stage. I had a similar experience with a Sapient interviewer – they scheduled the interview on Diwali (yes, that happens), which was a red flag itself. It usually shows that current employees are working over holidays, and they ask these questions to make sure you're mentally prepared for what's expected.