My company follows a strict policy:
- We ask candidates for their expected CTC before any interview.
- After the interview process we offer them the same CTC they mentioned.
- If a candidate asks for a CTC higher than our budget, we tell them upfront what our maximum is.
- For example, a candidate who asked for 30 LPA was given 45 LPA. We don't exploit anyone; most people end up earning roughly the same, with only minor differences.
- If a candidate asks for more after the interview, we immediately rescind the offer. No renegotiation, not even accepting the same amount – we just move the offer to the next candidate.
Because of this we've lost over 40 % of engineers. Many engineers with a 2‑plus‑month notice period try to renegotiate. One candidate even asked for a 20 % hike after the interviews; we simply marked it as a policy violation and moved on.
What are your thoughts on this policy?
If you're losing about 40 % of engineers because of that rule, the policy itself could be the issue. Negotiating after an offer is quite normal in tech, and turning people down outright for it will scare away good talent.
That policy is really short‑sighted.
If you want to be transparent, why not publish the salary range in the job posting or share the exact TC during the introductory call? Many companies do that and give everyone the same number. The whole "expected TC" thing just pushes candidates to ask for as high as possible.
If a candidate asks for more after the interviews you rescind the offer – negotiation is their right. If you have such a big ego, maybe you should make an offer that people can't refuse. Losing 40 % of candidates who cleared the bar doesn't make you smart; keeping positions open costs the company a lot of money.
Sure, candidates shouldn't re‑engage after they've accepted, but why not be flexible before that?
Can you explain what you mean by "policy violation"? Did you actually send the offer letter to the candidate?
That shows you're paying below market rate. Candidates can easily use your offer to negotiate better packages elsewhere, and other firms will gladly pay more.
Just as companies try to keep salary costs low, candidates have the right to ask for more.
If every company followed a similar rule, candidates would keep shopping around for offers.
Sounds like an ego problem. Please share your company name so my network can steer clear.
If you're losing good engineers, the approach isn't working. Do you need good engineers or just cheap ones?
In my current job there's no rescinding. They were very clear about the budget from the start and told me there would be no negotiation – zero negotiation from either side.
Maybe you should give that clarity right at the beginning.
Are you trying to find Yudhishtras for your company?
If you think a candidate asking for more after the interview is bad faith and you rescind the offer, think about the fact that you are the one pulling the job away just because they tried to negotiate.
Your company doesn't have the moral high ground – both you and the candidate are on the same level.
Please share your company's name so people can avoid it.
Do you realize that rescinding an offer directly impacts a person's life? In India, employers have an unfair advantage because of the oversupply of job seekers, which can lead to exploitation. A policy like this shows a lack of understanding of the Indian job market.