By the way, I'm not claiming either of these is the ultimate in its category.
(https://i.ibb.co/0PvfKv1/50ofcgt296ah1.jpg)
(https://i.ibb.co/d4J1t8sg/xwjpw9yz86ah1.jpg)
Hollow Knight has both.
Batman: Arkham City.
Gameplay over story any day.
Sekiro has the best gameplay.
Story wins for me. I get that good gameplay makes a game more fun, but I personally enjoy the story way more than the gameplay.
The only reason I play games is to dive into the characters' story and their journey.
10/10 gameplay for me, personally.
Expedition 33 offers both.
Are you suggesting Dark Souls doesn't have a 10/10 story?
Gameplay should be at least a 7-8, and the same goes for story. If either drops below that, I don't care if the other is 11/10; it's not good enough.
10/10 gameplay. Games are mainly about gameplay; a good story is just secondary.