eChat

Categories => Personal Finance & Investing => Topic started by: Bhavesh on Mar 21, 2026, 03:45 PM

Title: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Bhavesh on Mar 21, 2026, 03:45 PM
I'm totally confused between my dream SUV and a practical car, we've got a baby on the way and I need some advice

Hi everyone, I'm a 29 year old married guy working in Bangalore, my wife and I are both working professionals, I wanted to share my situation and get some advice from you all, my salary is around 2 lakhs per month, my wife's salary is around 1.5 lakhs per month, we've got a lot of expenses like home loan EMI, rent, medical expenses, and supporting our families, we're expecting a baby soon and I think we need a car, but I'm not sure whether to go for my dream car like XUV700 or Harrier or something more practical like Nexon, I can pay around 5 lakhs as down payment and take a loan for the rest, I don't want to make a financial mistake, especially with the baby coming and our existing responsibilities, so please help me out
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Ramesh on Mar 21, 2026, 03:50 PM
How is your wife earning so much when she just started her new job
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Shanta on Mar 21, 2026, 03:54 PM
You should tell us how you plan to use the car, what's your top priority, mileage, safety, maintenance, I think you should play it safe, you can ask for suggestions on Cars India
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Arnav on Mar 21, 2026, 03:55 PM
You should just buy a pre owned Swift for cash, no need for a loan, and then upgrade later
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Raj on Mar 21, 2026, 03:57 PM
It all depends on how many people will be using the car, how much you drive, where you drive, and where you live, and your emotions, no point buying a 25 lakh car if you'll only use it a few times a month
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Saad on Mar 21, 2026, 03:58 PM
You should buy a practical car that's easy to maintain, especially since you won't be driving that much
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Shivendra on Mar 21, 2026, 03:59 PM
I think you should go for a practical car for now, a car is just for going from point A to B safely, you can always upgrade later, if you buy an expensive car now the EMI will be more and raising a child will also cost money, you don't need to buy a budget car, just something balanced, safe and reliable, like Sonet or Venue or Brezza, or maybe a mid size sedan like Honda Amaze
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Shailesh on Mar 21, 2026, 04:01 PM
I think Nexon is a fairly good choice, I drive both Altroz and Harrier, Harrier is a great car but not recommended as a first car, I'm happy with my Altroz for now, it's practical, smaller cars are the best choice for you
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Vaishali on Mar 21, 2026, 04:04 PM
I really don't want to make a financial mistake, so I would suggest not going for Tata cars, unless you've got the money and time to spare, which I don't think you will after the baby arrives, go for Toyota or Suzuki or Hyundai or Kia instead, and congratulations on the baby
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Manav on Mar 21, 2026, 04:11 PM
What you need to do is make a list of all the expenses you will have for the baby and your family, kind of like what was mentioned earlier, and put it in an excel sheet. Also, dont forget to keep some money aside for emergencies. If after all this you can still manage to save some money, then we can think about the next steps.  The next thing to think about is what you need on a daily basis.  Will you be using your car to drive to work every day or just for the occasional road trip, which would need a bigger car, or will it just be sitting there most of the time? (and if you dont drive much, you should probably go for the petrol version).  I was in a similar situation myself, I really wanted to buy a Harrier, but I ended up getting an Amaze instead because I only drive around 3-4 kms every day and hardly ever take any long trips.  It didnt seem right to be paying 30k every month for a car that would just be sitting there most of the time.  Although I do plan to buy one eventually, it will be later on when my kid is older, around 10 years old, and I have some money saved up and more free time to go on trips and really enjoy the car.  So, considering all this, if you still think you want to buy the car, I say go for it, you only live once and you should make the most of every day.
Title: Re: Choosing between dream SUV and practical car with baby on the way
Post by: Juhi on Mar 21, 2026, 04:15 PM
I think you should go the practical way, dream cars are great but you've got to think about the running and upkeep costs, your usage doesn't seem like it'll be that much, so why buy something you'll only use occasionally, consider a second hand car from a trusted source, newer cars are expensive, second hand cars are the way to go, you'll pay less and it's easier to sell later if you need to, I like Honda but please check your own comfort and driveability, don't sacrifice that