eChat

Categories => Personal Finance & Investing => Topic started by: Nitin on Mar 14, 2026, 02:36 AM

Title: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Nitin on Mar 14, 2026, 02:36 AM
I checked out all the major platforms for investing in US and global stocks from India and here's what I found after 6 months and ₹65L+ invested

I keep seeing the same question about which platform to use for US stocks, so I thought I'd just write this up properly. I've actually used most of these platforms over the last 6 months and tracked my costs, so this isn't just me reading comparison blogs and repeating what I've read.  Quick background about me: I'm salaried, have RSUs from work, and my total global allocation is around ₹65L at this point.  

INDmoney: I started with INDmoney because it showed up in my Instagram ads. The whole pitch about tracking everything in one app got me.  

The good things: zero account opening fees, fractional shares, the whole experience felt very familiar if you've used any Indian app. Brokerage is 0.15% which looks fine. Best financial super app dashboard, still used for tracking MFs/FDs/EPF, US stock SIP feature, start with ₹1, free withdrawals with Federal bank.  

The problem: the FX conversion quietly destroyed me. They route through their own banking setup and the spread is genuinely bad. We're talking 2-3% hidden in the rate. On a ₹5L remittance that's like ₹10-15K just gone. I didn't even realize this until I compared with what I was getting elsewhere months later. Tax reporting is basically nothing, they give you USD statements and then it's your problem for Schedule FA. My CA charged me extra that year.  Also, it's US only. 

When I started reading about Irish domiciled ETFs and UCITS, I couldn't buy any of that on INDmoney.  If you're putting ₹1-2L just to try things out, sure INDmoney works. But don't scale here.  

Vested: Felt more like a proper investing app vs INDmoney which felt like a super app that happens to have US stocks.  

The good things: ₹250 one-time fee, onboarding was smooth, brokerage capped at $20 per trade which is nice. They have these thematic baskets which are kinda cool. UI is probably the nicest of all the platforms I used. Tax loss harvesting feature is actually useful.  

The problem: still US only. Still no Irish ETFs. And here's the thing that made me eventually move, if your US holdings cross $60K (roughly ₹50L), your nominees could get hit with up to 40% US estate tax. I'm not making this up. On ₹50L that's potentially ₹20L going to the IRS if something happens to you. This isn't some edge case, this is literally how the US taxes non-resident aliens on US situs assets.  

Nobody on Vested tells you this. I found out from a CA friend over drinks.  Also, $5 per withdrawal, and same story with tax reporting — USD statements, do it yourself for ITR.  Better than INDmoney for actual stock picking for sure. But the estate tax thing is a real blindspot.  

Interactive Brokers (IBKR direct):  Ok so after reading approximately lots of threads on this sub I opened IBKR. The consensus here is basically IBKR is king and yeah, for costs they are.  

The good things: cheapest brokerage period. Like $0.0035 per share for US stocks. Buying 100 shares of something costs you 35 cents. Access to literally every exchange — LSE, HKEX, Swiss, European, everything. I could finally buy CSPX and VWRA (the Irish ETFs). Interest on uninvested cash. The product is legit.  

The problem: the India side is a nightmare. Nobody tells you this part clearly enough.  First remittance through HDFC took me 3 weekends. Not 3 days. 3 WEEKENDS. My RM didn't know what Form A2 was. I had to explain LRS to the branch manager. Then FEMA purpose codes, god. TCS tracking? On you. Schedule FA? Completely on you. Everything is in USD, nothing is mapped to INR, your CA will hate you.  

If you genuinely enjoy doing all this tax stuff yourself and you're good with spreadsheets, IBKR direct is objectively the cheapest. No argument there.  Majority of portfolio is here. Because it's the cheapest and most trustworthy.  4%+ interest on idle cash, 40+ year track record, $400B+ in custody, Trader Workstation depth etc etc  

Paasa (IBKR-based): Someone in a thread here maybe 4-5 months ago mentioned this platform called Paasa. YC backed. I was skeptical because moving to a different investing platform is a task.  

What worked: Same IBKR custody and SIPC insurance. Same brokerage rates as IBKR direct (they don't add any commission on top). Access to global markets — US, UK, Europe, HK. Irish UCITS ETFs available. But here's where it actually saved me time — pre-filled LRS forms, they have tie-ups with HDFC/ICICI/Kotak/Axis for better FX rates (I was getting about ≤40 paisa markup vs Google rate, which is way better than what I was getting on my own). Schedule FA auto-generated in INR. My CA literally said why can't your other platforms do this. Best hai yeh.  

The managed portfolio thing (they call it Apex) has a $50K minimum and 1% AUM fee, which I haven't tried. Just using the free DIY access plan.  What didn't: Minimum $1,000 for first deposit from Indian bank. Can't log into IBKR directly (everything goes through their app).  

Verdict: So after 6 months and way too many accounts: Paasa seems the most practical. IBKR is the cheapest if you're willing to handle India compliance yourself, Paasa fills a pretty specific gap for people who want IBKR-level global access without the paperwork, INDmoney is the best all-in-one app if you only want US stocks as part of your overall financial tracking, and Vested is the best pure US investing experience with the nicest UI.
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Bhavana on Mar 14, 2026, 02:55 AM
what about something like Charles Schwab? I've heard it's pretty good  also, the HDFC thing is legit. genuinely stupid/slow employees.
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Norman on Mar 14, 2026, 02:56 AM
the UCITS thing is so real. I moved from Vested to Paasa earlier this year for exactly this reason, had crossed 45L and didn't want that estate tax sword hanging over my portfolio  honestly Vested's UI is still miles better for browsing and finding stocks. I miss that. but the compliance automation on Paasa saved me during ITR season. my CA usually charges 12k for foreign asset reporting, this time he was done in 30 mins and charged 3k lol  IBKR direct is definitely cheapest if you're comfortable with all the forms. I tried for 2 months gave up. worth paying a bit extra to not deal with bank RMs who don't know what LRS is
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Niraj on Mar 14, 2026, 03:04 AM
Few queries or doubts !  US estate tax is applicable to all! Why is it under Vested as a negative?  Vested and INDmoney use the same demat provider driverwealth! Discovery of stocks are limited to the provider albeit INDmoney can further filter the list  Vested with HDFC is a breeze with single day transfers  Vested or INDmoney since money goes to driver wealth I have used bank transfer option that also went through in two days from Equitas small finance bank
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Yash on Mar 14, 2026, 03:05 AM
good breakdown. one thing I'd add, INDmoney's dashboard for tracking overall net worth is genuinely best in class. I still use it just for the consolidated view even though I invest elsewhere  for actual investing moved to Paasa because of the Irish ETF access (CSPX gang represent). the FX rates are legit better than what my ICICI RM was giving me and the auto Schedule FA thing is clutch but yeah if you're just starting with like 50k-1L INDmoney or Vested are perfectly fine. the compliance stuff only becomes painful once you scale up
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Sharmila on Mar 14, 2026, 03:11 AM
as someone with tech company RSUs this post hits home. started with Vested realized the estate tax issue had a mini panic attack  tried IBKR direct first, lasted exactly one remittance cycle before I gave up. the Form A2 experience at HDFC branch was soul crushing. switched to Paasa after that they handle the runner pickup thing which honestly feels like magic compared to spending Saturday morning at the bank  Vested still has the best UI though. sometimes I open it just to browse stocks lol their thematic baskets are actually well researched  for anyone else with RSUs you can ACATS transfer from Fidelity/etrade directly into Paasa without selling. saved me capital gains tax
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Vaishali on Mar 14, 2026, 03:15 AM
wait so Paasa is built on IBKR but you can't login to IBKR directly? that feels weird to me. what if Paasa shuts down tomorrow? do we get access to our IBKR account then also 1% AUM for managed portfolios is steep af. that's 1L per year on a 1cr portfolio. for that money I can hire a proper wealth manager who'll actually customize things the LRS automation sounds convenient sure but is it really worth giving up direct IBKR access? genuinely asking because I'm considering this but the lock-in factor bothers me anyone here actually tried withdrawing everything and closing Paasa account? how did that go
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Firoz on Mar 14, 2026, 03:21 AM
Interesting writeup. few questions for OP or anyone who's used Paasa  1) you mentioned 1000 dollar minimum first deposit, is that hard limit or can you start smaller once account is open  2) the auto Schedule FA in INR, does it handle DTA calculations too or just basic reporting  3) how does the FX rate lock work? like when you initiate transfer vs when funds actually move  4) can you buy individual stocks or is it only ETFs  I'm at 8L invested in INDmoney right now thinking of moving once I hit 15L. Estate tax thing is legit scary had no idea about the 60k limit  also OP how long did ACATS transfer take from your old broker to Paasa? any issues
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Samar on Mar 14, 2026, 03:38 AM
INDmoney has a spread of 1-2% yes and that will eat away your money and you wouldn't know. But IBKR is costly if you're investing less than 1-2L each time. Paasa is relatively new and don't really trust it for now.
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Chandni on Mar 14, 2026, 03:38 AM
Do you think AMC Mutual fund investments that allow investments into USA Index, or Other countries like Japan, China, Europe and Brazil Market  Have similar tax-related problems that the investors face?  Or  Is everything dependent on AMC, as per the capital gains statements?
Title: Re: Investing in US and global stocks from India: My 6-month experience
Post by: Rekha on Mar 14, 2026, 03:48 AM
@OP You didn't give details about Irish domiciled ETFs and what's the deal with it. Can you elaborate on that?